Box ticking isn’t enough for investors, warns PwC

In a study of the narrative reporting habits of the entire FTSE 350, PwC
found that companies have upped their efforts to meet compulsory requirements of
the legislation, but were still below-par in disclosing optional information
essential to investors.

David Phillips, senior corporate reporting partner at PwC, said: ‘If
companies do not provide strategically relevant information as a matter of
course, they are more likely to find themselves in the unenviable position of
having their reporting challenged by the market and other observers. At the end
of the day, box-ticking compliance alone will not be enough for investors.’

PwC’s study praised corporates’ improving standard of narrative reporting, as
75% are now complying with the requirement to communicate key performance
indicators. Data showed 75% of the FTSE 350 are also clearly setting out their
principal risks and uncertainties.

But only 35% of companies support strategic statements with qualitative or
quantitative targets.

Only two thirds of companies align some, or all, of their KPIs with their
strategic priorities and these are invariably related to financial measures, PwC

On the whole, PwC backed the Business Review, which has been phased in since
the more demanding Operating and Financial Review was dropped at the end of
But it said there have been mixed reactions to the financial reporting
developments brought about by IFRS and the narrative and non-financial factors,
such as business strategy and market environment, covered by the Business

PwC highlighted the complexity and length of reporting which has led to
greater reliance on non-financial and contextual information.

Phillips added: ‘The Business Review poses some complex questions. It enables
critical information to be presented in a logical and integrated way essential
for an understanding of the long-term direction of the company and its
short-term performance, but companies need to go beyond legal requirements.’


Diageo CFO earns £1.5m

Nick Rose has scooped £1.5m for his financial stewardship of Diageo. In its
annual report the drinks giant disclosed that Rose’s base salary and bonus
contributed to a pay packet of £1.5m. Rose has been in the financial driving
seat of the booming corporate, which owns well-known brands such as Guinness,
Bailey’s and Smirnoff since 1 July 1999. This year Diageo made net sales of
almost £7.5bn. On paper, his windfall was beefed up further by long-term
incentive plan gains of almost £1.3m. The FTSE 100 giant’s accounts showed that
£795,000 of share options granted to Rose in 2004 vested this year, in addition
to him exercising options on £481,000 of shares.

Netstore’s Memory gain

David Memory has been hired as Netstore’s new CFO. The AIM-quoted corporate
said that Memory will assume financial control as of today. Memory, a chartered
accountant, was previously Group FD of Tie Rack for 12 years, steering the
company through a public to private transaction and the subsequent sale earlier
this year. The incoming FD, who was at PricewaterhouseCoopers for 15 years,
replaces Ian Daly who resigned last month. Netstore CEO Graham Kingsmill said:
‘I am delighted that David is joining our team, his strong financial management
background and experience working with the City will be a great asset to

Seven years of restatements

NASDAQ-quoted software provider UTStarcom Inc has been forced to restate
seven years of revenue after an audit found errors in its revenue recognition.
An investigation by the company’s audit committee, independent legal counsel and
forensic accountants found issues with the accounting treatment of sales
contracts in western China. The audit determined that revenue previously
recorded in the region was recognised earlier than it should have been.

Callan named as Lehman Brothers CFO

Lehman Brothers has brought in one of its most prominent investment bankers
asCFO. The US banking heavyweight announced that Erin Callan would become its
new financial chief in December. Callan will replace Chris O’Meara, who will
become global head of risk management. As CFO, Callan will oversee Lehman’s
finance operations including, treasury, tax, financial control and reporting.

Related reading