PracticeAccounting FirmsDirector ‘lied’ against Chantrey Vellacott in court battle

Director 'lied' against Chantrey Vellacott in court battle

Judge rules that director lied to bring a case of professional negligence against Chantrey Vellacott

A former director knew that accountants from Chantrey Vellcott were not
responsible for the failure of his company’s bid to win a $100m (£49m) project,
a judge has ruled.

Mr Justice Rimer said that former Convergence director Alan Robinson lied in
giving evidence on behalf of his company during litigation, which collapsed in
November, against the firm. The judge ruled that Robinson should be liable to
pay the vast majority of the firm and its insurers’ £5m legal fees, on an
indemnity basis.

The judge called Robinson ‘untruthful’ in giving evidence in a case his
company brought against Chantrey Vellacott.

‘In relation to key issues in the case I found him to be an evasive and
untruthful witness,’ said the judge. ‘I find that he knew from the outset that
CV were in no way the cause of the failure of the Silk Route Project.’

An indemnity award should see the firm and its insurers recover 90% of the
case’s £5m legal fees, compared with 60% to 70% under a standard award.

‘Our insurers incurred substantial costs in defending us and the focus will
now be on extracting those costs from those responsible for pursuing the
dishonest claims against us,’ said Chantrey Vellacott partner Ralph O’Beirne.

Solicitors acting on behalf of Robinson were unable to comment as
Accountancy Age went to press.

The case centred on Convergence’s £150m claims for negligence against CV.

Convergence, a telecoms business that is now in administration, had claimed
that CV’s actions had cost the company a $100m contract known as the Silk Route
Project.

But when Convergence entered into administration its administrators were not
prepared to fund the court action.

Further reading:

Judge throws out claims against Chantrey
Vellacott

Related Articles

Sexual harassment – is accountancy next for #MeToo?

Accounting Firms Sexual harassment – is accountancy next for #MeToo?

2d Karen Baxter, Lewis Silkin
Johnston Carmichael CEO appointed as ICAS president

Accounting Firms Johnston Carmichael CEO appointed as ICAS president

3w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
British Accountancy Awards 2018 – entries open!

Accounting Firms British Accountancy Awards 2018 – entries open!

1m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Is the accountancy sector facing an international talent crisis?

Accounting Firms Is the accountancy sector facing an international talent crisis?

1m Lewis Silkin
RSM appoints new Chief Operating Officer

Accounting Firms RSM appoints new Chief Operating Officer

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
RSM announces 11 partner promotions

Accounting Firms RSM announces 11 partner promotions

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
BDO hires former AstraZeneca creative director as head of digital and innovation

Accounting Firms BDO hires former AstraZeneca creative director as head of digital and innovation

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
What does the future hold for listed accountancy firms?

Accounting Firms What does the future hold for listed accountancy firms?

2m Fergus Payne, Lewis Silkin