As innocuous as they may once have seemed, the incriminating nature of emails
produced as evidence in US corruption trials has forced executives to rethink
the expense of managing delicate electronic documents.
The cost of e-dicovery revealing documents in the run up to a trial may
also have chief financial officers worried as evidence emerges that the process
can rack up fees in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.There are numerous
examples where electronic documents are in evidence. At present, emails
involving Enron’s former CEO Jeffrey Skilling are being used by the prosecution
at the fraud trial taking place in Houston.
Next month, at the fraud trial of former Computer Associates CEO Sanjay
Kumar, the government will produce e-documents related to the infamous 35-day
months that CA allegedly worked to ensure the financials met Wall Street
No less damning for defendants is the inability to produce emails that were
destroyed, but should not have been because there was a likelihood of
litigation. Take the example of financier Ronald Perelman’s suit against Morgan
Stanley, in which he claimed the bank misled him into overpaying when he bought
appliance maker, Sunbeam.
As the bank did not produce relevant documents before the trial, the judge
awarded the case to Perelman and the jury awarded him $1.45bn (£0.8bn) in
Not surprisingly, the bank is appealing, but Morgan Stanley’s troubles do not
end there. Its lack of disclosure drew the attention of watchdogs, the
Securities and Exchange Commission and the National Association of Securities
Dealers, and it probably faces multimillion dollar fines from both.
Besides the costs associated with litigation, corporate CFOs are beginning to
baulk at the actual cost of the e-discovery process. Anecdotally, one case is
said to have rattled up e-discovery expenses in eight figures, and researchers
say $140,000 is the minimum per suit.
With those kind of fees on tap, it is not surprising that a whole industry
has appeared, consisting of dozens of companies that have developed a variety of
technologies to either find and analyse documents needed in litigation or,
better still, help businesses keep a handle on their electronic documents before
a lawsuit is filed.
EDDix, a special research company, estimates the e-discovery industry will
generate $2bn in revenues for vendors this year and it has compound growth of
Many companies, though, are not yet prepared. According to research from
Gartner, nearly every civil court case in the developed world now involves
e-discovery, but still more than half of IT organisations and in-house legal
teams are not geared up to handle requests for electronic evidence.
Even more alarming, 65% of corporations do not include electronic documents
in their document retention schemes, according to consultancy Cohasset
Tech companies have created tools to take a corporate record retention policy
and bridge the gap to a process down to the desktop level.
Those tools have the capability to know when documents are created; codify
what those documents are related to; and keep those documents from being
destroyed in case there is litigation.
Another proactive action that companies can take is to archive their
e-documents in such a way that those most likely to be subject to compliance or
litigation reporting and disclosure are put in near-line storage and not hidden
away on tape drives in a back room somewhere.
With such technology available, companies may have no excuse if they are
taken to trial.
If businesses do not take cyber security seriously in their business planning regulators may do it for them, the ICAEW has warned
Just one half of UK practices have implemented a pricing structure around auto enrolment implementation and advice - with many suffering increased costs
Deloitte's north-west Europe foray; BDO, Smith & Williamson investment paths; Shelley Stock Hutter; and Wilkins Kennedy discussed by editor Kevin Reed on our Friday Afternoon Live broadcast
New BDO managing partner Paul Eagland reflects with Accountancy Age on which historical figure he would like to seek advice from - and what they would advise