Ruling on off-street parking VAT could hurt council pockets
Local councils could be forced to pay VAT on a range of services in areas
where they compete with the private sector after a European Court of Justice
recommendation on off-street parking.
Councils had taken HMRC to court, alleging that they did not have to pay VAT
because they were not competing with the private sector in the parking area.
But the ECJ said that, in assessing the issue, any competition that was more
than negligible would result in the councils paying VAT. It also said that an
overall verdict on the issue needed to be reached, rather than simply working it
out on a council-by-council basis.
Marc Welby, VAT partner at BDO Stoy Hayward, said other council services
could be affected, including crematoria, welfare and child-care services.
Welby led the case for the councils and added he was optimistic they could
win when the case comes back to the High Court because there was no evidence
councils competed with the private sector. He said any resolution to the case
would be unlikely for at least another year.