TechnologySweeteners drive IT competition

Sweeteners drive IT competition

A new report by the National Audit Office shows that sweeteners paid to businesses to ensure a smooth transition from one to the other could have gone too far.

When IT supplier EDS lost out on its lucrative £3bn contract with HM Revenue
& Customs, Capgemini took on the onerous responsibility of getting the
department’s ailing systems on track.

Getting on track, it seems, has been achieved to a certain degree with tax
advisers experiencing fewer problems working electronically with HMRC in recent
times.

But a new report by the National Audit Office shows that sweeteners paid to
businesses to ensure a smooth transition from one to the other could have gone
too far. With Capgemini paid £37.6m and EDS £5.7m, the NAO report says: ‘there
remains a question whether the department needed to pay this much’. It appears
that another price has been paid to ensure smoother service.

With a number of massive projects to undertake, including the preparation of
the construction industry scheme, tax credits scheme and modernising PAYE,
budgets for the first year of the ten-year deal were busted; £539m to June 2005,
compared to an estimated figure of £384m.

The NAO warns that current spending would see the final cost of the contract
in excess of £6bn, rather than the projected £3bn to £4bn. Yet projected
declining staff numbers and increased use of electronic delivery sees HMRC
estimate this level of cost will not be sustained. There are lessons to be
learned, says the NAO and concerns for the future.

To avoid IT project delays the NAO has called for not many ongoing crucial
projects to be underway at any one time, which could put too much pressure on a
potential new IT supplier. The sheer scale of the contract, which now
encompasses both the Inland Revenue and Customs & Excise IT, could make a
barrier to effective competition for the tender.

And despite concerns over the incentives made to Capgemini and EDS, the NAO
concedes that to achieve effective competition this type of approach will have
to be considered.

Related Articles

Riding the wave of digital accounting

Technology Riding the wave of digital accounting

3w Xero | Sponsored
EU divided over radical tax reforms targeting tech giants

Corporate Tax EU divided over radical tax reforms targeting tech giants

3w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Deloitte cyber-attack: Is your firm safe?

Security Deloitte cyber-attack: Is your firm safe?

4w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
What to expect from GDPR

Legal What to expect from GDPR

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Making Tax Digital – still full steam ahead?

Making Tax Digital Making Tax Digital – still full steam ahead?

3m Margaret Curran
A brief guide to Making Tax Digital

MTD A brief guide to Making Tax Digital

1m Clear Books | Sponsored
Four reasons why tech investment is critical for accountants

Technology Four reasons why tech investment is critical for accountants

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Artificial intelligence and machine learning – the inevitable changes in professional service firms

Technology Artificial intelligence and machine learning – the inevitable changes in professional service firms

2m Andrew Griggs