MNEs face increased transfer pricing fines from HMRC

MNEs face increased transfer pricing fines from HMRC

HMRC fines targeting multinational enterprises have increased dramatically over the past two years under new regulations.

MNEs face increased transfer pricing fines from HMRC

HMRC fines targeting multinational enterprises’ (MNEs) transfer pricing have increased tenfold in the last two years, according to Freedom of Information (FOI) data obtained by LCN Legal.

For MNEs, transfer pricing agreements stipulate what one company charges another for a transaction. While these agreements are required for intercountry agreements, MNEs can carry a higher risk of potential tax loss.

Paul Sutton, partner at LCN Legal, said: “Transfer pricing remains an area of growing focus not just for HMRC but for tax authorities around the world.

“HMRC has scaled up its capabilities in this area and is devoting more resources to scrutinising the transfer pricing arrangements of multinational businesses.”

According to LCN Legal’s report, MNEs received £413,437 in fines in 2018/19 – a nine-fold increase from the £45,600 imposed in 2015/16 – from HMRC’s increased scrutiny.

However, LCN Legal notes that HMRC would rather reach a settlement than impose a penalty. By challenging transfer pricing arrangements, HMRC grew its tax haul from £504m in 2012/13 to £1.6bn in 2017/18.

Country by Country

To avoid additional taxation, MNEs are required to share their global income, profit, tax and economic activity information through Country by Country reporting. This increases transparency for companies and regulatory bodies like HMRC, limiting the need for investigations.

However, Country by Country reporting only came into effect in 2017, and Sutton believes the initial December 2017 deadline is a cause of the sharp jump in HMRC fines.

“It is likely that some multinationals had not adequately managed the risks associated with the introduction of Country by Country reporting and had failed to plan for the greater transparency their transfer pricing arrangements would be subjected to,” Sutton said.

According to gov.uk, this reporting structure is only obligatory for roughly 300 UK-headed MNEs, with an additional 200 non-UK headed MNEs affected for at least a year.

While those businesses required to submit to Country by Country reporting are at an increased risk of fines, HMRC recently changed its model to catch potential problems before they progress.

Adjusting the system

In January 2019, the Profit Diversion Compliance Facility was launched to help MNEs declare their arrangements accurately and bring their tax affairs up to date.

“HMRC has scaled up its capabilities in this area and is devoting more resources to scrutinising the transfer pricing arrangements of multinational businesses,” Sutton said. “It wants to work with multinationals to put their tax affairs in order and is generally reluctant to impose fines.

“The increase in fines does suggest, however, that HMRC is increasingly prepared to use the stick in as well as the carrot.”

Sutton recommends that MNEs safeguard themselves with intercompany agreements, protecting against audits and challenges from both HMRC and other tax administrations.

Resources & Whitepapers

The new rules of accounting

The new rules of accounting

2m
5 ways internal productivity can boost your profitability

5 ways internal productivity can boost your profitability

2m
Crushing the Four Barriers to Growth

Crushing the Four Barriers to Growth

2m
Make MTD work for you

MTD Make MTD work for you

2m

Related Articles

IR35: HMRC launches updated CEST tool

HMRC IR35: HMRC launches updated CEST tool

2w Chris Jewers
New IR35 briefing offers support for businesses and comfort for contractors

HMRC New IR35 briefing offers support for businesses and comfort for contractors

2m Leanna Reeves
Myths about HMRC's powers means it can overreach in civil inspections, experts warn

HMRC Myths about HMRC's powers means it can overreach in civil inspections, experts warn

2m Leanna Reeves
HMRC fraud investigations to have netted more than £610m since 2016

HMRC HMRC fraud investigations to have netted more than £610m since 2016

2m Leanna Reeves
Chancellor Sajid Javid opens talk on inheritance tax

HMRC Chancellor Sajid Javid opens talk on inheritance tax

2m Leanna Reeves
ATT calls for clarity on off-payroll changes

HMRC ATT calls for clarity on off-payroll changes

2m Leanna Reeves
HMRC wins IR35 case against three BBC presenters - Reaction

HMRC HMRC wins IR35 case against three BBC presenters - Reaction

3m Chris Jewers
For charities, MTD regulation deadline is just around the corner

HMRC For charities, MTD regulation deadline is just around the corner

3m Leanna Reeves