Incoming FCA chair admits “error in judgement” over investment in tax avoidance scheme

Incoming FCA chair admits “error in judgement” over investment in tax avoidance scheme

Randell took responsibility for the mistake but said the scheme had been discussed with senior policy officials at HMRC “who had indicated that they approved of it”

Incoming FCA chair admits “error in judgement” over investment in tax avoidance scheme

The Financial Conduct Authority’s incoming chairman admitted to investing in a tax avoidance scheme which forced him to repay £114,000 to HMRC, describing it as “an error in judgement.”

Appearing before the Treasury select committee for a hearing into his appointment, Charles Randell took responsibility for the mistake but said the scheme had been discussed with senior policy officials at HMRC “who had indicated that they approved of it.”

He added: “It is clear to me now that, far from taking any comfort from that, I should have seen it as a warning signal, because the mere fact that an informal assurance was seen to be necessary should have told me that this was an investment for which there was no specific statutory framework.”

Randell said that he dispensed of the services of his financial adviser who promoted the scheme to him in 2013 after HMRC wrote to him about his involvement as an investor.

The Ingenious Film Partners 2 LLP scheme used specific accounting treatments for producing films to reduce investors’ personal tax liability, and attracted many famous investors, particularly footballers.

After a tax tribunal found that elements of the scheme constituted tax avoidance in 2016, some investors sued Ingenious Media.

Committee chair Nicky Morgan questioned whether Randell could understand how to ordinary people – “I mean those who are not seeking to be FCA chair” – the scheme would appear to be a “rather clever tax wheeze”, to which Randell replied “yes I can.”

She noted that the scheme provided investors in the first year an amount of tax relief equal to the value of the investment.

Randell was previously partner at law firm Slaughter & May and was appointed as FCA Chair earlier this year. He will take up the role from 1 April.

Related Articles

Brexit: HMRC estimates “max-fac” model or “no deal” could cost £20bn

Brexit & Economy Brexit: HMRC estimates “max-fac” model or “no deal” could cost £20bn

3w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
HMRC scaling back digital projects to ‘release project capability to EU Exit work’

Brexit HMRC scaling back digital projects to ‘release project capability to EU Exit work’

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
HMRC rate of return on large business investigations increases by 17%

HMRC HMRC rate of return on large business investigations increases by 17%

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
HMRC’s refusal to raid top Tory donor Lycamobile to be investigated by MPs

Big Four HMRC’s refusal to raid top Tory donor Lycamobile to be investigated by MPs

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
HMRC opens Making Tax Digital Income Tax pilot to all self-employed

Business HMRC opens Making Tax Digital Income Tax pilot to all self-employed

3m Lucy Skoulding, Reporter
What are the implications of HMRC’s IR35 victory against BBC presenter?

HMRC What are the implications of HMRC’s IR35 victory against BBC presenter?

4m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Guide to Making Tax Digital for individuals

HMRC Guide to Making Tax Digital for individuals

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Is HMRC’s increased VAT take unfairly impacting small businesses?

HMRC Is HMRC’s increased VAT take unfairly impacting small businesses?

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter