PwC found negligent by US judge over Colonial Bank’s $2bn fraud

PwC found negligent by US judge over Colonial Bank's $2bn fraud

A US federal judge has said that the firm failed to respond to red flags and will now consider whether PwC should be liable for damages

PwC found negligent by US judge over Colonial Bank’s $2bn fraud

PwC auditors were negligent as they failed to detect over $2bn fraud at Alabama’s Colonial Bank which led to its collapse in 2009, according to a US federal judge.

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) incurred a cost of $2.8bn after Colonial’s collapse and brought a professional negligence claim against PwC.

US district judge Barbara Jacobs Rothstein said that as auditor of parent company Colonial BancGroup, PwC failed to perform adequate checks and could have done more to prevent the bank’s collapse.

The multi-billion dollar fraud centred around mortgage company Taylor, Bean & Whitaker, Colonial Bank’s largest client, who overdrew its bank account over a period of years and covered it up by fraudulently selling Colonial mortgages that had already been sold.

As the fraud was uncovered Taylor, Bean & Whitaker filed for bankruptcy in August 2009 and Colonial Bank followed soon after.

Several senior executives at the mortgage company and bank were found guilty in the conspiracy that spanned 2002-2009 and were subsequently jailed. Taylor Bean’s founder and chairman Lee Farkas was sentenced to 30 years in jail in 2011.

Although Judge Rothstein accepted that PwC may have been deceived by the scheme, she stated that the firm missed red flags regarding reports that detailed a series of fake mortgages with illogical dates.

PwC noted that although the judge granted the professional negligence claim, it rejected four of the five claims put forward by the FDIC and Colonial Bank.

The judge will now separately consider whether PwC should be liable for damages, a figure which could reach billions.

The Big Four firm said it looks forward to “the damages phase where the FDIC will bear the burden of proof on what remains of their inflated damages claim.”

The judge stated that Colonial would not be able to claim damages due to its role in the fraud.

In 2016 the bankruptcy trustee for Taylor, Bean & Whitaker sued PwC for its negligence as auditor of Colonial Bank, seeking $5.5bn in the biggest accounting negligence lawsuit to ever go to trial. The firm eventually settled for an undisclosed sum.

At the time of bankruptcy Colonial Bank had $25bn in assets, making it the sixth biggest bankruptcy in US history.

PwC was recently hired by Steinhoff to independently review audits undertaken by Deloitte in which accounting regularities were found.

Whitepaper

The Future of Finance is in the CFO's Hands

Business The Future of Finance is in the CFO's Hands

2m
Save a Week a Month Consolidating Accounts

Accounting Software Save a Week a Month Consolidating Accounts

3m
Mitigating Risk Through Internal Control

Legal Mitigating Risk Through Internal Control

3m
Could tax season have run more efficiently?

Corporate Tax Could tax season have run more efficiently?

4m

Related Articles

Audit of the future

Audit Audit of the future

5d Andy Turner, Audit and Business Advisory Partner
PwC audit changes are “unacceptable”

Audit PwC audit changes are “unacceptable”

1w Tom Lemmon
PwC reveals “big deal” tech plan to boost audit quality

Audit PwC reveals “big deal” tech plan to boost audit quality

2w Dave Beach
Grant Thornton to up audit quality with new appointment

Audit Grant Thornton to up audit quality with new appointment

2w Dave Beach
Goldman Sachs chooses Mazars for audit – but does it really matter?

Audit Goldman Sachs chooses Mazars for audit – but does it really matter?

4w Tom Lemmon
KPMG UK announce new audit structure – but is it enough?

Audit KPMG UK announce new audit structure – but is it enough?

1m Tom Lemmon
The CMA has released its final report into the future of the audit market

Audit The CMA has released its final report into the future of the audit market

2m Beth McLoughlin, Managing Editor
The madness of audit independence

Audit The madness of audit independence

2m Clive Viegas Bennett, CEO of MGI Worldwide