Court upholds ruling against HMRC’s position in Sports Direct EU VAT case

Court upholds ruling against HMRC’s position in Sports Direct EU VAT case

The Upper Tribunal Court has upheld a ruling in favour of Sports Direct and against HMRC’s position that the retail company owed millions in EU VAT

The Upper Tribunal Court has upheld a ruling in favour of Sports Direct and against HMRC’s position that the retail company owed millions in EU VAT.

Typically companies selling goods to EU customers would have to adhere to the VAT rate of the buyer’s country. VAT varies quite drastically across the EU –  the 20% rate in Britain comes out middle of the pack, and it reaches 27% for Hungary, 25% for Denmark, Sweden and Croatia, and down to 17% for Luxembourg.

Sports Direct found a way to circumvent paying varying amounts of VAT by setting up a separate delivery company, Etail Services Ltd, which operated outside of its VAT group. When a non-UK customer purchased goods online, Etail would purchase the goods from Sports Direct, then make the delivery and charge the customer inclusive UK VAT. The retail company used this structure between 2010-2015.

While initially approved by HMRC, the structure was called into question in 2015, when HMRC requested non-binding guidance from the European Commission’s VAT Committee on the arrangement. The VAT Committee found that such structures were in violation of Articles 32 to 34 of the EU VAT Directive, which led to HMRC declaring Sports Direct had wrongfully charged Etail UK VAT which it could not reclaim until it had paid any outstanding foreign VAT.

In 2016 Sports Direct took the case to the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) to challenge HMRC’s position, and the FTT ultimately ruled in Sports Direct’s favour, and suggested referral to the European Court of Justice (ECJ).

HMRC appealed the ruling and took the case to the Upper Tribunal Court, who upheld the FTT’s ruling in favour of Sports Direct, although did not support a referral to the ECJ.

HMRC recently announced the appointment of two new director generals.

Resources & Whitepapers

How to optimise your compliance lifecycle

How to optimise your compliance lifecycle

4m
The new rules of accounting

The new rules of accounting

4m
5 ways internal productivity can boost your profitability

5 ways internal productivity can boost your profitability

4m
Crushing the Four Barriers to Growth

Crushing the Four Barriers to Growth

4m

Related Articles

Podcast: Inside Accountancy episode 11 - IR35 has instilled a ‘fear culture’

Accounting Standards Podcast: Inside Accountancy episode 11 - IR35 has instilled a ‘fear culture’

2w Tom Lemmon
CTCs herald new era of control for tax authorities

Corporate Tax CTCs herald new era of control for tax authorities

3w Tom Lemmon
Why is cloud document storage important for AML regulations?

HMRC Why is cloud document storage important for AML regulations?

3w Alexandra Hayter
Digital marketplaces should shoulder VAT responsibility

HMRC Digital marketplaces should shoulder VAT responsibility

3w Jeremy Chan
HMRC updates internal guidelines in midst of IR35 review

HMRC HMRC updates internal guidelines in midst of IR35 review

1m Shannon Moyer
Deloitte pursues KPMG over audit of Goals Soccer Centres

Audit Deloitte pursues KPMG over audit of Goals Soccer Centres

1m Chris Jewers
IR35: HMRC launches updated CEST tool

HMRC IR35: HMRC launches updated CEST tool

3m Chris Jewers
New IR35 briefing offers support for businesses and comfort for contractors

HMRC New IR35 briefing offers support for businesses and comfort for contractors

4m Leanna Reeves