LAPFF urges FTSE 350 companies to disregard the FRC

LAPFF urges FTSE 350 companies to disregard the FRC

The UK’s largest listed companies should disregard the accounting advice of reporting watchdog the FRC, a group of investors have urged chairmen of FTSE 350 businesses

THE UK’s largest listed companies should disregard the accounting advice of reporting watchdog the FRC, a group of investors have urged chairmen of FTSE 350 businesses.

The Local Authority Pension Fund Forum (LAPFF), whose 71 members have £175bn in assets, has written to the chairman of the FTSE 350 companies and urged them to disregard the FRC’s advice over the application of defective accounting standards.

The move is the latest development in a long-running row between investors and regulators over inconsistencies between IFRS and existing company law when calculating the level of dividend payments.

LAPFF claims that documents released by the former Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) under the Freedom of Information Act undermine the FRC’s claim that its interpretation of the law on true and fair is backed by government.

“LAPFF believes that the FRC has been doing its job badly because it’s been reading the law wrongly. What matters to investors is that companies do the right thing,” said Kieran Quinn chair of LAPFF. “We have had to make clear that the FOI reveals that the government did not agree with the FRC position.”

Legal advice provided to the LAPFF from George Bompas QC had previously identified inconsistencies between IFRS and existing company law, suggesting directors must override the accounting standards in order to comply with competing legislation.

The FRC has repeatedly dismissed claims that international accounting standards conflict with UK company law as misguided by UK policymakers, and suggested that government agreed with legal advice taken by the FRC from company law counsel Martin Moore QC.

Moore found that IFRS is legally binding and achieves a true and fair view in financial statements and could, in most instances, be achieved by complying with the rules

“We were surprised by FRC claims that the government agreed that LAPFF and Mr Bompas was wrong. The FOI reveals that it didn’t. It’s time the FRC did its job properly by regulating in accordance with the law,” said Quinn.

In a statement, the FRC said: “The FRC discusses policy issues on a regular basis with central government as this FOI response shows.

“Our position on this issue is clear: the Companies Act 2006 does not require the separate disclosure of a figure for distributable profits. Ultimately interpretation of the Act is a matter for the courts.

“The FRC stands by what it has previously said on this matter. It was aware that the LAPFF had written to company chairmen in late 2015. Their letter dealt with a very narrow point of company law in terms which we cannot support and which raises uncertainty unnecessarily. The LAPFF’s new letter is drawing on emails regarding a draft statement. The final version of the statement was agreed with BIS.”

Whitepaper

The Future of Finance is in the CFO's Hands

Business The Future of Finance is in the CFO's Hands

4m
Save a Week a Month Consolidating Accounts

Accounting Software Save a Week a Month Consolidating Accounts

5m
Mitigating Risk Through Internal Control

Legal Mitigating Risk Through Internal Control

5m
Could tax season have run more efficiently?

Corporate Tax Could tax season have run more efficiently?

6m

Related Articles

IFRS to bring significant changes for lessee accounting

Accounting Standards IFRS to bring significant changes for lessee accounting

4w Dom Longley, lead consultant for accounting solutions for Smith & Williamson
FRC audit inspection finds no improvement on last year

Accounting Firms FRC audit inspection finds no improvement on last year

1m Chris Jewers
Sustainable cost accounting - The reality of the climate crisis requires nothing less

Accounting Standards Sustainable cost accounting - The reality of the climate crisis requires nothing less

2m Richard Murphy
Feedback led to change in FRS102 on Director’s Loans

Accounting Standards Feedback led to change in FRS102 on Director’s Loans

2m Tom Lemmon
IFRS 17 is an “opportunity” for accountants

Accounting Standards IFRS 17 is an “opportunity” for accountants

2m Tom Lemmon
Moody’s Analytics enhances accounting and reinsurance capabilities of RiskIntegrity IFRS 17 solution

Accounting Standards Moody’s Analytics enhances accounting and reinsurance capabilities of RiskIntegrity IFRS 17 solution

2m Tom Lemmon
What will IFRS 16 mean for 2019’s reporting season?

Accounting Standards What will IFRS 16 mean for 2019’s reporting season?

3m John Kuett, Vice president of European Lease Accounting at Lease Accelerator
Kingman has missed the point

Accounting Standards Kingman has missed the point

8m Richard Murphy