Alliance Trust bonus payment errors missed by Deloitte auditors

Alliance Trust bonus payment errors missed by Deloitte auditors

Errors led to payments to former executives were set to high

AN INDEPENDENT INQUIRY has been set up at investment fund Alliance Trust as to why bonus payments to two former executives were set too high and the errors missed by its auditors.

New chairman Lord Smith of Kelvin told the annual meeting in Dundee that the £2.8bn trust had paid out 32.5% of the maximum, based on the trust’s performance, but “on investigation we agreed the vesting should be lower at 27%”, the Herald Scotland reported. The mistake meant the total rewards for ex-CEO Katherine Garrett-Cox and former finance director Alan Trotter for 2015 had been “slightly overstated”.

Asked by Lord Smith to comment, Deloitte audit partner Calum Thomson said: “We tested bonuses on a sample basis – unfortunately they didn’t pick up the errors.”

The downward adjustment to the two directors was more than £100,000.

Shareholders raised concerns over the potential for reputational damage as a result of the error, having made similar mistakes “a few years” before, which led to senior managers having to repay overpayments.

Gregor Stewart, deputy chairman, told the AGM the trust is “committed to a full investigation of this…we aim to get to the bottom of it this time”.

Deloitte has been contacted for comment.

Resources & Whitepapers

How to optimise your compliance lifecycle

How to optimise your compliance lifecycle

4m
The new rules of accounting

The new rules of accounting

4m
5 ways internal productivity can boost your profitability

5 ways internal productivity can boost your profitability

4m
Crushing the Four Barriers to Growth

Crushing the Four Barriers to Growth

4m

Related Articles

Deloitte pursues KPMG over audit of Goals Soccer Centres

Audit Deloitte pursues KPMG over audit of Goals Soccer Centres

1m Chris Jewers
Brydon Report: Industry reacts to findings and audit recommendations

Accounting Firms Brydon Report: Industry reacts to findings and audit recommendations

2m Chris Jewers
Can technology solve the audit crisis? Key takeaways from our latest podcast

Audit Can technology solve the audit crisis? Key takeaways from our latest podcast

4m Tom Lemmon
Deloitte auditor accused of recklesness at FRC tribunal

Audit Deloitte auditor accused of recklesness at FRC tribunal

4m Shannon Moyer
Deloitte's FTSE350 proposed cap would present mid-tier firms with audit opportunity

Audit Deloitte's FTSE350 proposed cap would present mid-tier firms with audit opportunity

5m Chris Jewers
Audit news round-up - Deloitte top of the world, PCAOB finds audits lacking

Audit Audit news round-up - Deloitte top of the world, PCAOB finds audits lacking

6m Chris Jewers
Audit news round-up

Audit Audit news round-up

6m Chris Jewers
Mazars make the case for joint audit - Part 2

Audit Mazars make the case for joint audit - Part 2

7m Tom Lemmon