Contractor rules are 'too vague', says Redston
Anne Redston, professor of tax law at Kings College, says areas around so-called ‘substitution’ clauses are still unclear following the Dragonfly case
Anne Redston, professor of tax law at Kings College, says areas around so-called ‘substitution’ clauses are still unclear following the Dragonfly case
Rules on contractors’ tax affairs are still too vague, an expert has warned.
Following last week’s Dragonfly case, which again tested the controversial
IR35 rules, Anne Redston, professor of tax law at Kings College, London, said
areas around so-called ‘substitution’ clauses are still unclear.
The right to substitute an alternative if a contractor cannot do the work
required is seen as a key litmus test as to whether or not the contractor is
self-employed.
IT consultancy Dragonfly failed to overturn a tax demand for £99,000, since
its contractual absolute right to substitution was not matched by the reality of
the situation.
Redston said the case highlighted that a more limited right to substitute an
alternative would not get contractors past IR35 rules.
‘They’re all cases in the grey area, but each time one of these cases goes to
court it draws the line more firmly in the sand for freelancers,’ Redston said.
Redston said while the outcome of the Dragonfly case came as a disappointment
to the freelance fraternity, it wasn’t a surprise.
‘This judge hasn’t changed anything. It’s shone a much brighter light on
substitution,’ she said.
In the past decade, the professional services industry has transformed significantly. Digital disruptions, increased competition, and changing market ...
View resourceIn recent months, professional services firms are facing more pressure than ever to deliver value to clients. Often, clients look at the firms own inf...
View resourceIn a world of instant results and automated workloads, the potential for AP to drive insights and transform results is enormous. But, if you’re still ...
View resourceThe first phase of Making Tax Digital (MTD) saw the requirement for the digital submission of the VAT Return using compliant software. That’s now behi...
View resourceGlobal spend on accountancy outsourcing up by 40% in the space of five years. News comes as accountancy outsourcing specialist AdvanceTrack reports en...
View articleFollowing a profitability review, Deloitte has decided to scale back its UK deals business due to lower returns. This strategic shift could lead to jo...
View articleUK-based Dow Schofield Watts (DSW), a mid-market professional services network, announced the creation of a new division called DSW Principal Partners...
View articleEY has been undergoing significant cost-cutting measures and streamlining its operations since the abandonment of Project Everest. The firm has made t...
View articleTransitioning from an accounting firm to a consultancy model is only one part of the puzzle. The next, equally vital piece is making the market aware ...
View articleThis framework, while providing a top-line view, underscores the importance of strategic vision, operational excellence, and the spirit of continuous ...
View articleLooking ahead, the Big 4 firms face a challenging year, with ongoing cost-of-living concerns, slow economic growth, rising geopolitical tensions, and ...
View articleLast month it was reported that Deloitte would be cutting approximately 1,200 jobs in the United States, making it the latest of the Big Four accounti...
View article