Sony and Nintendo face controller patent suit

Lawsuit centres on wireless controller systems

Written by Ian Williams

Nintendo and Sony have been slapped with a lawsuit claiming that both companies infringe on a patent filed in 1996 by the Copper Innovations Group.

The lawsuit, filed in the Pennsylvania Western District Court on 27 December 2007, concerns a 'hand held computer input apparatus and method'.

Patent 5,640,152 claims a "method for remotely controlling a function of a computer monitor or other equipment in response to transmissions from less than all of a plurality of transmitters remote from said equipment".

In essence the patent describes a way to sort the inputs to a system from a group of transmitters by designating and comparing identification numbers assigned to each transmitter.

According to the suit, the technology used to connect the Sixaxis controller to Sony's PlayStation 3 and the Wii-mote to Nintendo's Wii violates the Copper Innovations Group patent.

The Blu-ray Remote Control and Wii Nunchuk were also named as infringing products.

It is unclear why Microsoft has not been named in the suit for its Xbox 360 controller, but some have speculated that it is because the device is not motion sensitive and does not use Bluetooth.

The suit will be particularly bad news for Sony, which has just ended a long patent spat with Immersion over the rumble feature used in PS2 controllers.

Copper Innovations Group is seeking financial damages, interest and legal fees, as well as an injunction prohibiting Sony, Nintendo or their agents from further infringing on the patent.

All parties were unavailable for comment at the time of writing.

Enjoyed this article? Help spread the word:

Comments

Reader comments for this story

White papers

Related jobs

Spotlight

Accountants and the crisis: the outlook - ready for the worst

The downturn is hurting and forecasts of recession hang heavy...

PwC 10-year anniversary special report

Relive how the controversial mega-merger of Price Waterhouse and Coopers...

Make partner fast with YP

The latest edition of Young Professional features our definitive guide...

Find your next job

Find your next job
Salary Checker

Newsletters

Sign up here for the very latest news delivered to your inbox. Choose from the following options:

Search white papers

Search white papers

Have your say

Fair value accounting has attracted a lot of criticism, but is it actually fair?
Yes, it's better than any other method available.
No, it's caused too much trouble. Get rid.
It's promising but could work better with modifications.

Job of the week

More finance jobs...

Your next job