Yahoo
executives received a roasting from Congressmen from both sides of the political
spectrum in an emotionally charged hearing of the
US
House Foreign Affairs Committee.
Yahoo chief executive Jerry Yang and general counsel Michael Callahan were
being questioned about the arrest of Chinese human rights activist
Shi
Tao, which occurred after Yahoo handed over his user information to the
authorities.
"While technologically and financially you are giants, morally you are
pygmies," said Democratic Committee chairman Tom Lantos, according to the
New
York Times.
Lantos urged both executives to apologise to Shi Tao's mother, who was
sitting directly behind them. They acknowledged her, but said nothing.
Meanwhile, Republican Congressman Chris Smith compared Yahoo's stance to
companies that cooperated with the Nazi regime.
Callahan argued that Yahoo had no choice but to operate under local laws. He
has also apologised for unintentionally giving
misleading
evidence on the matter.
"I cannot ask our local employees to resist lawful demands and put their own
freedom at risk even if, in my personal view, the local laws are overbroad," he
said.
When Callahan pointed out that Yahoo's China operations were now run by
Chinese company
Alibaba.com,
Smith called the practice "plausible deniability".
Yahoo has a 40 per cent stake in Alibaba. Other investors include
Cisco Sy
stems and
Softbank.
Alibaba shares doubled
in price to value the company at $25.7bn during its first day of trading
yesterday in Hong Kong.
During further questioning Callahan stated that Yahoo could not say whether
the company was going to help Shi Tao and his family.
He also could not say whether Yahoo had been asked for information on anyone
else in China, or that it would react differently if the situation arose again.
Callahan did, however, state that Yahoo would be taking lessons from its
experience in China when opening a new business in Vietnam.
"I would hope to have a structure in place ... that we would be able to
resist those demands or have that data not be accessible," he said.
Comments
Have your say on this article