Economic uncertainty seems to have increased the rate at which software and
IT services companies listed on the London Stock Exchange are being acquired,
particularly by overseas competitors and private equity groups.
Between March 2007 and March 2008, as many as 15 IT companies announced
recommended offers. In April, four more vendors announced they were in takeover
discussions, or had already agreed deals.
In most cases, the prices paid were significantly above the level that stock
market investors were valuing the company. In fact, premiums of 50 per cent or
more are quite common. At
Close Brothers, we
believe that the rate of IT acquisitions, and subsequent stock market delisting,
reflects several factors.
First, many software stocks look cheap relative to the basic fundamentals of
the market, with many firms’ price-earnings ratios at, or near, an all-time
low.
Second, business models in the software and IT industry have become more
robust. Increasing emphasis is now placed on recurring revenue and cashflow
generation, both of which are attractive to buyout groups that want to create
new opportunities.
Third, unlike the situation in the technology downturn of 2001, there is a
lot of money sitting with recently raised private equity funds and on the
balance sheets of larger technology companies, especially in the US. This
provides an opportunity for software firms to finance consolidation in what is
still a very fragmented industry.
An acquisition is almost always a disruptive event for the acquired company.
The principle underlying logic of merger and acquisition (M&A) is that cost
savings can be made from eliminating overlapping functions and growth
opportunities will be enhanced by creating a broader range of products and
services to sell.
Long-term benefits
The immediate and most brutal effect on the target company’s employees is the
risk of redundancy, especially in areas such as sales, finance and
administration and particularly in senior management. There is also the
challenge of integrating cultures, especially in cross-border transactions. But
an acquisition can create new career opportunities and better long-term
employment security for the people who stay.
Customers of merged IT firms are likely to experience similar short-term
disruption, but enhanced longer-term opportunity. Personnel changes may result
in new styles of account management and new sales and delivery relationships
that take time to bed down.
But IT leaders are also likely to benefit from a broader and stronger range
of products and services.
Customers may be concerned that the acquisition of a supplier could threaten
the development and support of a core system. Although vendors might have
longer-term plans to migrate users of legacy products to new systems, it is rare
that an acquiring company will risk losing customers by killing product lines.
From technology leaders’ perspective, the ultimate threat of M&A leads to
the dominance of a supplier in one particular market. Such dominance could lead
to there being no competition to regulate prices, or to incentivise suppliers to
seek innovation and service quality.
Anti-trust legislation plays an important role in preventing a lack of
competition and even the most mature customers still enjoy substantial choice in
many segments of the IT market.
So far there is little sign that recent takeover activity has reignited
investors’ interest in the London-listed IT sector. But while public market
sentiment remains weak, overseas predators and private equity firms will benefit
and there will be further activity in 2008.
Paul Lewington is a director at
Close Brothers
Corporate Finance
Comments
Have your say on this article