Concerns over the economy are causing all three political parties in the UK
to shy away from the green agenda for fear of alienating voters, according to a
new report backed by the UK's largest environmental groups.
While the parties' rhetoric is sometimes impressive, it is often not
supported with policy, and there appears to be a worrying lack of consistency,
the report found.
"None of the three main parties are currently showing the vision and courage
to prepare the UK for the challenges ahead," said Stephen Hale, director of
Green Alliance. "In a time of
rising fuel and food costs, the need for an ambitious approach to environmental
policy has never been clearer."
The Alliance cites a
Guardian/ICM
poll from July as evidence that politicians' fears that the public are more
concerned about the economy than the environment are misplaced.
That survey found that 52 per cent of respondents believed the government
should prioritise environmental problems, with just 44 per cent claiming
economic problems should be the top concern.
The Green Alliance - which includes Friends
of the Earth, WWF and
Greenpeace – is calling on the parties
to re-commit to the green agenda at the upcoming party conferences and follow up
their previous rhetoric over climate change with solid policy commitments.
"They must step up to the mark and commit to our proposals for action on
energy efficiency, renewables, coal and aviation," said Hale. "There is no other
credible alternative."
The report says that despite a steady increase in environmental legislation
the government's approach to green issues has been "contradictory and incoherent
".
It argues that instead of using rising fuel prices as an opportunity to
promote home generation and renewables, it has encouraged the view that there is
a trade-off between economic and environmental objectives, citing energy
minister Malcolm Wicks's recent claim that "We are not going to sacrifice fuel
poverty on the altar of climate change".
Meanwhile, Conservative leader David Cameron is accused of holding green
issues at arms' length after initially making the environmental agenda a key
plank of his "decontamination" of the Tory brand.
Despite encouraging speeches and moderate opposition to new coal-fired power
stations, the Conservatives have no clear plans or policies on tackling climate
change, and at a press conference in May spelling out future priorities for the
party, David Cameron failed to mention the environment at all.
The Alliance is concerned that
a
third of Tory MPs questioned by a ComRes survey in July questioned the
existence of man-made climate change, and is also worried that an elected
Conservative government would slowly return to this more traditional base.
In a recent interview, George Osborne said that green taxes would replace or
complement existing taxes, rather than adding to them – an approach the Alliance
praised because it does not set up the economy and the environment in
opposition.
Last year, David Cameron appointed former Ecologist editor Zack
Goldsmith as his chief environmental advisor, but when questioned recently said
he was "one of many advisors" – effectively distancing himself from the green
evangelist.
Meanwhile, the Liberal Democrat's bold announcement to make the UK
energy-independent and zero-carbon by 2050 was welcomed by the alliance, but it
again raised concerns that the party should have made the environmental issues a
more central aspect of its attempts to differentiate itself from the two main
parties in the past year.
The report's findings are likely to be seized on by opponents of
environmental legislation as further evidence that green regulations will be
sidelined as politicians seek to address growing economic concerns.
However, with all three major parties committed to passing the government's
climate change bill this autumn, any attempts to back away from green issues are
likely to be short-lived once legally binding emission reduction targets are
formally adopted.
Comments
Have your say on this article