Like most people, I am extremely susceptible to the power of suggestion.
Consequently, I am truly rubbish at poker, endlessly fascinated by hypnosis and
will usually try to steer well clear of drug dealers and cult leaders.
So upon strolling round the new Scottish headquarters of building services
firm NG Bailey and
hearing about its natural ventilation system, I could not be sure if the air
seemed so much clearer because I was being told that was the case or if this
office was in fact the workplace equivalent of some Highland fell, all fresh air
and open spaces.
The thing is though, it really did seem fresher – at least when compared to
the rather stuffy workplaces I have become used to, where both the temperature
and staleness of the air is entirely determined by the distance you are forced
to sit from the air conditioning unit.
In contrast, NG Bailey's new
Solais House
is decked out with temperature, light and carbon dioxide sensors that feed into
a central building management system, which calculates when the air is getting
too hot and stuffy and automatically opens the appropriate windows or draws the
correct blinds.
The opened windows themselves are positioned high up against the ceiling to
exploit the fact that an air stream will stick to a surface. Consequently, when
the windows open the air flows along the ceiling to the middle of the room where
it drops down to ground level, precisely where the bulk of the desks in the
open-plan office are situated.
Obviously, natural air ventilation has its limits when the natural air itself
has been the subject of a summer heatwave (an unlikely occurrence in Scotland
admittedly, but not unknown). So dotted throughout the building in receptacles
in the ceiling are so-called
phase change
materials, paraffin-based substances designed to melt at 26 degrees
centigrade, soaking up five times as much heat as concrete as they do so.
Solais House's near zero-carbon ventilation system is just one of the
features that has allowed the otherwise anonymous-looking building in
Strathclyde's business park to become the first standard office building in the
UK to attain the government's A-rated energy performance certificate. And
according to NG Bailey's chief executive Mark Andrews, the certificate and
accompanying 42 per cent reduction in energy bills compared with a conventional
building of the same size have been achieved with established and relatively
mature technologies.
"Solais House is a showcase of what can be done with existing technology in a
typical developer spec building," he said at the opening of the office last
week, adding that almost all the features included in the 150-seat block could
be scaled up to larger developments and would deliver a return on their initial
investment within an average of five years.
Of course, keeping the building cool on a warm afternoon at the start of
autumn such as the day on which I visited is less of a challenge in Scotland
than keeping it warm in the winter, but again NG Bailey is confident that a
number of further low or zero-carbon innovations will ensure that, unlike at
least one office I have worked in, there will be no need for scarves and mittens
to be worn at peoples' desks during the winter months.
For example, the building faces directly due south and the office has a glass
front (double glazed, of course) and several large roof lights, both of which
ensure that not only is 80 per cent of the building lit almost entirely by
sunlight, but on clear days it captures as much of the sun's energy as possible.
Meanwhile, a bore hole sunk beneath the semi-permeable car park surface to a
depth of 120m draws up the water required to feed a ground source heat pump.
Tucked away in an adjacent outhouse, the heat pump takes the ground water, which
is already naturally heated to between 11 and 13 degrees centigrade, and
compresses it to a level where it is warm enough to heat the building. According
to NG Bailey, the heat pump delivers three kilowatts of energy for every one
kilowatt it takes to run it, making it far and away one of the most efficient
means of space heating available.
Another form of renewable energy is on the building's windows and rooftop
where photovoltaic (PV) glass and a solar water heating array are to be found.
Solar panels may seem a strange choice in a country that is rightly renowned for
its inclement weather, but NG Bailey claims that even during this miserable
summer it has managed to generate 350KW/h in the six and half weeks since the
solar PV windows became operational, while the solar water heater is providing
up to 60 per cent of the hot water the building requires.
This hot water serves the bathrooms and showers that are arguably the most
impressive feature of the building. I am not often impressed by toilets, but
those at Solais House really are worthy of mention. Provided by a Swedish
company, they have a square-shaped bowl that means they use just two litres (of
rainwater collected from the roof) per flush compared with the standard six
litres per flush. Meanwhile, waterless urinals are expected to save more than
800,000 litres of water a year and highly polished "sun tubes" work like a
child's kaleidoscope, bouncing daylight down into these internal rooms. Like I
say, it's a pretty impressive toilet.
Unsurprisingly, all these green features come at a price. NG Bailey reckons
the building cost £850,000 more than a comparable office of the same size – a
sginficant premium for a development with a total price tag of £5.5m.
It is a premium that many firms will be reluctant to pay, according to CBI
director general Richard Lambert, who observed at the opening of the building
that the payback period would have to fall from the five years NG Bailey is
expecting if these various technologies are to be adopted more widely. However,
he added that this was likely to happen as energy bills continued to climb and
energy-saving technologies mature further.
There are also questions to be asked about the net carbon savings given that
separate offices in Glasgow and Edinburgh have been moved to the new site,
meaning some staff will have a longer commute.
However, NG Bailey is confident that a new car-pooling scheme and commuter
bus service will help tackle transport-related emissions and the company is
adamant that the financial case for such buildings stacks up, particularly when
you consider the numerous "soft" benefits that can be realised in terms of staff
retention and productivity.
"Companies need to look beyond the traditional ROI [return on investment]
when looking at these types of developments," Andrews argues. "If people want to
come to a building because it is a nice place to work, that makes a big
difference. It is difficult to put that sort of thing on a balance sheet, but it
does have value."
Andrews has a point, and as he observes increases in productivity and
retention rates of just a few percentage points would deliver significant
financial and commercial benefits over and above the £3.3m in reduced energy
bills the company expects to save over the 60-year life of the building. And
that is even before you consider the potential savings that would be realised in
the event of a carbon tax by a building that emits just 13kg of CO2 pr metre
squared compared with 41kg for a conventional office.
NG Bailey will have to wait and see if the fresh air, big windows and pride
at working in a green building does indeed lead to greater staff motivation once
the initial gloss has worn off, or if it was all down to the power of suggestion
in the first place. But as I return to my stuffy central London bunker my money
is firmly on the former.
Comments
Have your say on this article