The Cern Laboratory has rejected suggestions from the UK's former chief
scientist that projects such as its Large Hadron Collider, nick-named the "God
Machine", is distracting valuable resources from climate change research,
insisting that the lab could help deliver numerous new clean technologies.
Speaking ahead of the presidential address at the BA Science Festival in
Liverpool yesterday, Sir David King told reporters there was a need for a "
re-think of priorities in science and technology" to increase the focus on
solving practical challenges such as climate change.
Advertisement
In a thinly veiled swipe at the Cern Laboratory's research to try and find a
mechanism that explains why matter has mass – which will reach a major milestone
tomorrow with the turning on of the world's largest particle accelerator, the
Large Hadron Collider – hinted that much of the funding donated towards pure
science projects should be diverted to fund research into clean energy.
"It's all very well to demonstrate that we can land a craft on Mars, it's all
very well to discover whether or not there is a Higgs boson [a potential mass
mechanism]," he said. "But I would just suggest that we need to pull people
towards perhaps the bigger challenges where the outcome for our civilisation is
really crucial."
However, James Gillies, spokesman for the Cern Laboratory, rejected outright
King's criticism, insisting that the Lab's research was likely to deliver
numerous "spin off" discoveries, many of which could benefit the environment and
help tackle climate change.
"I don't think King has the slightest point," he told
BusinessGreen.com. "Major advances can always be traced back to
fundamental science. If when Isaac Newton was working on the laws of motion,
someone said that he should be focusing on medical research that would be very
persuasive, but what he achieved has underpinned countless technical advances."
Gillies added that the work undertaken at Cern had already provided the
foundations for numerous breakthroughs in cancer research, noting that of the
17,000 particle accelerators used around the world half are housed in hospitals.
He also argued that the lab had also undertaken research that could help in
the treatment of radioactive waste. Citing work by the Nobel Prize winning
physicist Carlo Rubbia into whether particle accelerators could be used to
develop a new form of nuclear energy based on thorium rather than uranium,
Gillies explained that it was now thought that accelerating protons into lead
results in the release of neutrons that can simultaneously be used to break up
radioactive waste material in the form of polonium and trigger a reaction in
thorium that releases nuclear energy.
"The research Cern did in the 1990s suggests that using thorium [as a nuclear
fuel] is entirely plausible," said Gillies. "It is an energy efficient reaction,
with no possibility of a chain reaction and no long term waste storage issues."
In addition to research on the treatment of nuclear waste, Cern is also using
Proton accelerators to model the impact of cosmic rays on cloud formation – a
phenomenon that is not yet fully understood and is sometimes seized upon by
global warming sceptics as a means of suggesting man's impact on the climate may
not be as pronounced as many climate scientists believe.
Gillies also predicted that the discoveries made by the Large Hadron Collider
would have numerous other spin off applications that are not yet fully
understood. "We are categorically not saying that there should not be more
research on climate change," he said. "But pitting one form of science against
another is not the way forward... discoveries made here will deliver benefits
for hundreds of years as people work out how to apply the new understanding that
is gained."
Comments
Have your say on this article