The US Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA) is guilty of consistently distorting science for political reasons and
pressuring its staff scientists to water down the green regulations and
guidelines they are working on.
That is the conclusion of a
major
investigation from the Union of Concerned
Scientists (UCS), which found that of nearly 1,600 staff scientists over
half claim to have experienced political interference in their work in the past
five years.
Furthermore, almost a third of respondents claimed to have personally
experienced frequent or occasional "statements by EPA officials that
misrepresent scientists' findings", while 31 per cent felt they could not speak
candidly within the agency.
Francesca Grifo, director of UCS's Scientific Integrity Program, said the
investigation revealed "an agency in crisis" and warned that "distorting science
to accommodate a narrow political agenda" posed a serious threat to the
environment.
The report also found that political interference is most pronounced in
offices where scientists are involved in writing regulations and at the National
Center for Environmental Assessment, where many of the risk assessments that
shape future legislation are undertaken.
"The investigation shows researchers are generally continuing to do their
work," said Dr Grifo. "But their scientific findings are tossed aside when it is
time to write regulations."
Moreover, much of the interference was alleged to have come direct from the
White House's Office of Management and
Budget (OMB) with one respondent claiming that "OMB's power needs to be
checked as time after time they weaken rulemakings and policy decisions to
favour industry."
The report will increase pressure on the EPA as the agency prepares to face a
series of rulings over its failure to impose stringent enough environmental
regulations.
Congress is investigating administration interference in a new chemical
toxicity review process and the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee
is expected to hold a hearing into political interference in the new EPA
ground-level ozone pollution standard early next month.
Meanwhile, the EPA is also preparing to defend itself against
legal
action from California and 12 other states over its refusal to grant
approval to the states' plans to impose their own car emissions standards.
Comments
Have your say on this article