ECJ to deliver tax blow to Treasury

The UK Treasury looks set to be handed a 'thoroughly unwelcome Christmas present' on Thursday, as the European Court of Justice finally delivers a ruling on the Lankhorst-Hohorst tax case.

Written by David Rae

link: Revenue fights it out in biggest ever tax case

The case has been described by City law firm Linklaters as one of the most monumental ECJ judgements in the taxation field and involves a challenge to German 'thin' capitalisation rules.

If the ECJ rules in favour of the taxpayer, multinationals could be looking at a windfall worth millions, and the chancellor a debt to the tune of billions.

In a preparatory opinion, the advocate-general of the ECJ came down in favour of the taxpayer. In almost all cases his opinion has been upheld by the ECJ.

Simon Whitehead, a partner at law firm Landwell, said the ECJ is extremely likely to favour the taxpayer. 'It's come around incredibly quickly compared to the usual waiting times for the ECJ,' he said.

'The expectation is that it will follow the opinion because there hasn't been enough time to change it.'

Figures handed to Accountancy Age by a source close to one of the cases, show that if all ECJ cases are won by the taxpayer - and history shows the success rate at almost 100% - the Treasury will be out of pocket by some £5bn. Individual claims from multinationals average at £5m, but with some in the region of £100m.

Enjoyed this article? Help spread the word:

Comments

Reader comments for this story

White papers

Related jobs

Spotlight

Profile: Ian Powell, chairman of PwC

Being number one isn't enough for PwC chairman Ian Powell....

Credit crunch special: guiding business through the storm

The downturn is hurting and recession looms. Will accountants be...

Beat the credit crunch with Young Professional

Latest issue features a guide to advancement during economic uncertainty,...

Find your next job

Find your next job
Salary Checker

Newsletters

Sign up here for the very latest news delivered to your inbox. Choose from the following options:

Search white papers

Search white papers

Have your say

Will the 2012 London Olympics provide a boost to business?
Yes, such a high profile event can't fail but to help the economy
No, any gains won't match the amont of money spent on the event

Job of the week

More finance jobs...

Your next job