Professional indemnity

Legal advice: writ large

Professional indemnity insurance covers your costs should the dreaded day come when you are sued by a client

Written by David Jetuah

It's not as improbable as you think… No accountant looks forward to the prospect of being dragged through the courts by a vengeful client, but it's a feature of life that can't be ignored. As the debate surrounding limited liability rages, the issue has become even more pressing, especially as aggrieved companies are being given greater access to huge pools of money to bankroll claims.

Not only does professional indemnity insurance protect your business against compensation sought by a client if you have made mistakes or been negligent in some or all of your services, it crucially provides cover for the legal costs.

'I already know that', you may say, but getting the right legal advice is key, especially in terms of pre-emptive moves to do all you can to avoid a claim.

The fallout from a claim just being lodged against you by a prominent company, let alone the eventual repercussions, can be severely damaging in reputational terms, so your legal representation must be fully aware of the business climate in which you and your clients inhabit.

These may seem obvious points, but there are key questions you should ask any prospective legal representation to ensure they are up to scratch if things do go wrong.

One of the most high-profile cases being dragged through the courts at the moment involves mid-tier player Moore Stephens. The firm is currently on the wrong end of a £90m negligence suit over its role as auditor to Stone & Rolls, a collapsed British company linked to a Croatian businessman Zvonko Stojevic that is being bankrolled by litigation funding. The claim against Moore Stephens is being funded by IM Litigation Funding, a UK company.

To date, it is the largest claim in the UK involving independent litigation funders.

Peter Ellingham, a partner at City law firm Kennedys, says: 'This case illustrates the growing trend of seeking to blame auditors for the results of fraud within companies. In that context, litigation funding is a concern to auditors and their professional indemnity insurers.'

Future moves

The future for accountants may become a lot more hairy as the legal firms' involvement in the case is taken up a few notches. Insurers are clearly not going to welcome the current situation because they are usually responsible for funding the defence of such claims, but a new form of the controversial funding could make the situation even more acute.

Sector experts are keeping an eye on the growth of a different litigation funding mechanism, under which the law firms involved in the case assume a degree of risk in the outcome of a trial.

The concept of a 'plaintiffs' bar' is an established feature of the US system of justice. It allows lawyers to share with their clients in the proceeds of litigation. At the moment, these arrangements are not yet permissible in the UK, but Stateside there has been a massive growth in litigation funded by conditional fee arrangements, that is, contracts in which lawyers accept a share of the risk in the outcome of the litigation in exchange for an uplift on the fees they would earn in the event of a successful outcome. A number of US plaintiff law firms have recently set up branch offices in the UK and elsewhere in Europe or have expressed an interest in doing so.

It's not all bad news, though. Jeremy Cole, litigation partner at law firm Lovells, says: 'The flipside of losing can be severe for the funder. In those circumstances, the funding used to bring the claim has been lost and the funder may well pick up some of the other side's legal costs. This potential exposure could keep the lid on the funding of marginal claims.'

Useful tips

One important aspect to bear in mind when considering professional indemnity insurance is that, because there can often be a long delay between an event and a subsequent claim, you need to be covered both at the time of the event and when the claim is made. Also, if you plan to change insurers, you will either need to arrange run-off cover or get agreement from your new insurer to accept new claims for prior incidents.

Everyone automatically focuses on the aggrieved client, but if the worst comes to the worst and you lose the case, what can you do if you're not happy with the service that your legal eagles have provided?

First, you should write directly to the person who handles complaints in your solicitor's business. This person should have been named in the client-care letter your legal team provided when they started working for you. Outline exactly what the problem is and ask them to confirm who will deal with it and how quickly they will do so. If your complaint is about your bill, you should do this quickly as time limits apply if you need to take the complaint to the next level.

If you cannot reach agreement through your lawyer's internal complaints procedure, you can take your complaint to the Law Society's Consumer Complaints Service (CSS). This is an independent body that will try to arbitrate between you and your solicitor. It can also award compensation if appropriate. You can find details on how to take a complaint further on the Law Society website (www.lawsociety.org.uk). The progress of the complaint depends on whether it involves court action that has already taken place or is forthcoming.

Even if a complaint has not been resolved, you may need to pay at least part of your solicitor's bill. Check with the CCS helpline for more detailed advice. If the CCS cannot resolve the complaint to your satisfaction, you may be able to complain to the Office of the Legal Services Ombudsman (OLSO) about the CCS.

The OLSO is unlikely to examine your original complaint - it usually only looks at how it has been handled by the CCS. Do they understand the nature of your business? If not, it's often helpful to provide them with a written sum mary.

If a claim goes all the way, you must hope that your lawyers will be able to see you through the storm, but in this case the journey is almost as important as the destination.

Key questions you should ask a prospective lawyer

1. Are they happy to take you on as a client and comfortable with the work you want them to do?

2. Are they qualified to act for you? Do they have a practising certificate issued by the Law Society?

3. What hourly rate will they be charging?

4. Do they think what you are looking to achieve is realistic? If so, will they outline the steps they think you need to take to achieve it?

5. Will they explain things in clear plain language and not confuse you with legal jargon?

6. Will they provide you with real practical solutions and not just a legal commentary on your case?

7. Will they agree methods and frequency of keeping in contact, using face-to-face meetings, telephone, letters or email?

8. Can they provide you with a client-care letter that sets out their terms of business and complaints procedure?

9. Can they outline what other services the firm may be able to provide as your business develops?

Enjoyed this article? Help spread the word:

Comments

Reader comments for this story

Also Read

White papers

Related jobs

Spotlight

Find your next job

Find your next job
Salary Checker

Newsletters

Sign up here for the very latest news delivered to your inbox. Choose from the following options:

Search white papers

Search white papers

Have your say

Will the 2012 London Olympics provide a boost to business?
Yes, such a high profile event can't fail but to help the economy
No, any gains won't match the amont of money spent on the event

Job of the week

More finance jobs...

Your next job