Regional catastrophe but international blip for PwC

PwC in India has found itself uncomfortably connected to the Satyam scandal, in which the chairman of the Indian outsourcing company admitted fraud believed to be worth more than $1bn (£650m)

Written by Accountancy Age

While there is no evidence of any auditor wrongdoing, PwC’s very association with a company where such a huge fraud has been committed is potentially hugely damaging, as clients may start to bail out through fear of being associated in turn with the scandal.

But experience suggests that unless a scandal is in the US, it’s unlikely to affect the global business. When PwC’s affiliate in Japan, ChuoAoyama, found itself embroiled in a scandal it was hugely damaging for the business in Japan but the firm internationally was unaffected. It was the same when Grant Thornton International got caught up in Italy’s Parmalat scandal.

Advertisement

It seems that scandals outside the US just don’t carry the same reputational risks ­ although any firm that made that assumption in its own risk assessment would be courting commercial as well as ethical suicide.

So why the dual standard? Well, the business world looks to the US for its lead: if bad things happen there, it must be bad. There is also perhaps an assumption that corruption is a given in some parts of the world, and therefore not so damaging because it’s par for the course.

So here’s a prediction. Satyam could be horrible for PwC in India, but the effect on PwC worldwide will be negligible.

The day a reputational scandal in India or China really does bring down a global business is the day the world acknowledges that the global balance of business power really has shifted from the West to the East.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Print

Comments

White papers

Related jobs

More Accounting jobs

Spotlight

Big Four audits are off the pace

Smaller firms top the list of the best audit services...

Change of climate

As a top UN green expert joins KPMG, competition is...

Intellectual capital: in sickness and in health

The profession still has lessons to learn about the value...

More finance jobs

Search thousands of finance jobs:

Find your next job

Hiring now on AccountancyAgeJobs.com:

Your next job

Related finance jobs

Search thousands of finance jobs:

Find your next job

Newsletters

Sign up here for the very latest news delivered to your inbox. Choose from the following options:

Newsletters

Have your say

Following the PBR, who do you think should reside in No. 11?
Alistair Darling
George Osborne
Vince Cable

Advertisement

White papers

How to make better financial decisions - Free FD Handbook

When reviewing your business and accounting software, this free two- part guide explains all you need to know.

The Future of the Financial Close: Automating Account Reconciliations and Review

Many firms have made account reconciliation automation the focus of their drive. This paper describes why.

More white papers

Advertisement

White paper library

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; IThound.com brings you over 6,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.