alex hawkes

Regulators: how to keep number one in check

People are always insisting that print journalism is in decline ­ a situation that makes me wonder whether I should think about a career change? If so, I know what I should be ­ - a regulator.

Written by Alex Hawkes

People always seem to want regulators, someone to oversee this or give an opinion on that. It’s a growth industry.

This week we heard more and more calls for regulatory intervention. Prime minister Gordon Brown has even set up a new agency at local government level to ensure there aren’t too many agencies spewing out too many regulations.

I dread to think what its first job will be. Issuing a regulation against regulation, perhaps?

The ICAEW is up to it too. Senior figures want an ombudsman to protect members, who may suffer under the new public disciplinaries being mooted.

Of course, it may be suggested it is hypocritical of a journalist to criticise regulation. Newspapers create much of the noise demanding that things are looked into and made more transparent.

And doing away with what we contemptuously refer to as ‘red tape’ risks, on the other side of the coin, letting go of what may well be valuable checks on unscrupulous behaviour.

But it’s important to take a broader view of regulation, to target it at the issues that matter and remove it elsewhere.

For instance, multi-nationals are too lightly regulated. Why shouldn’t they report on a country-by-country basis? It would be cumbersome, but they make mind-boggling amounts of money and seem to have to answer to no one.

Government agencies don’t need an over-arching regulator to stop them regulating, either. If a new rule is silly, we can all tell them so in print, in parliament and in public generally.

In short, there’s already a body to regulate regulators ­ - us.

Alex Hawkes is the news editor of Accountancy Age

Enjoyed this article? Help spread the word:

Comments

Reader comments for this story

Also read

White papers

Related jobs

Spotlight

Find your next job

Find your next job
Salary Checker

Search white papers

Search white papers

Have your say

Are online bankruptcies a good thing?
Yes, this is the 21st century after all
No, it makes it too easy to abuse

Job of the week

More finance jobs...

Your next job