Public sector outshone by its private cousin

When the Government Hundred Group sits down for its inaugural meeting next month, there will be plenty to discuss

Written by Alex Hawkes

The new body, comprised of those finance directors in Whitehall and elsewhere who control the biggest chunks of taxpayers’ money, will be faced with some scepticism about governance and control issues in the public sector.

The challenge they face is to instill faith in the integrity of government accounting. Mary Keegan, in her interview on page 15, defends against criticisms that the public sector is not up to the standard of its private sector counterparts. Government auditors pick up small mistakes and regard them as material; private sector auditors do not, she argues.

Looking at the list of achievements in public sector accounting, you could be forgiven for wondering what all the fuss was about. Whitehall has moved to resource accounting. Its accounts are now slicker, more professional and more transparent than ever before. But even in its successes, government accounting reveals how far it has to go.

The fact that there weren’t many qualified accountants in Whitehall until now is shocking enough. And the creation of a Government Hundred Group betrays a view that private sector accounting is better. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.

The most damaging stories on government accounting emanate from stories such as those at the DWP, where the accounts have been qualified for nearly 20 years. The Government Hundred Group should think about what it plans to do about that. If it believes that the problems are overstated due to the auditing methods of the NAO, perhaps those should change. Otherwise the public sector, by reputation if not reality, will continue to be the private sector’s poorer cousin.

Enjoyed this article? Help spread the word:

Comments

Also read

White papers

Related jobs

More Accounting jobs

Spotlight

Find your next job

Find your next job

Advertisement

Salary Checker

Newsletters

Sign up here for the very latest news delivered to your inbox. Choose from the following options:

Search white papers

Search white papers

Advertisement

Have your say

Should fair value accounting be suspended in the wake of the market crisis?
Yes, it's a big part of the problem
No, don't shoot the messenger

Job of the week

More finance jobs

Advertisement

Your next job