Jaimie Kaffash

Tax Hack

A blog by Jaimie Kaffash, Accountancy Age’s tax reporter

ad

Ain't tax avoidance great?

03 Aug 2006

  • Digg
  • Tweet

I've been criticised for saying unpleasant things about the NatWest Three (like they should be punished if they're guilty, an astonishing suggestion, I think you'll agree). But I'm holding my line that the Americans deal with white collar misbehaviour far more effectively than we do.

Fresh evidence has emerged this week with the Senate report on tax havens and tax abuses. Now I'm not suggesting that HM Revenue & Customs isn't doing a good job on avoidance, but our MPs rarely muster the combination of passion and investigative skill on the subject displayed here.

Those who know the background will remember that the Permanent Sub-Comittee on Investigations, which authored the report, is the same committee that delved into the issue a few years back, and whose remarkable study of avoidance then led to DoJ moves to possibly indict KPMG. They are also the committee that George Galloway came up against last year, but supporters of Gorgeous George should, in my opinion, not let that bother them.

They shouldn't let that bother them because the latest report is another masterpiece of forensic investigation.

The headline is in the first paragraph: 'Experts estimate that Americans now have more than $1 trillion in assets offshore2 and illegally evade between $40 and $70 billion in U.S. taxes each year through the use of offshore tax schemes.'

But the real joy of it is in the detail. Listen to this paragraph from one participant in what you can only describe as a shady offshore scheme:

'Mr. Johnson had tentatively decided to invest by December 20, 1999, when Mr. Scheinfeld emailed Mr. Wilk and Mr. Greenstein: “Joel [Latman] called, he has given us the full speed ahead (whatever than means) . . .” Mr. Greenstein asked in response “Are we firm on 100 or 200 [million dollars]?” and Mr. Wilk answered “$300MM; 150 for [redacted by Subcommittee] and 150 for Woody. Ain’t capitalism great!” On January 11, 2000, Chuck Wilk emailed Larry Scheinfeld “Well I guess congratulations are in order but boy do we have our work cut out for us now on POINT,” and Mr. Scheinfeld replied “Now I just hope Woody doesn’t get cold feet or have the IRS select his return for audit!”'

There, in all its glory, is the world of aggressive and dubious tax avoidance. Vast sums of money, and a clear realisation from those involved that what they are getting up to is barely legal. And the arrogance of that 'Ain't capitalism great?' line.

It looks like we are, at the very least, in for another bout of serious blood letting across the pond about the extraordinary activities of US tax practitioners.

Adding your comment

We won't publish your address

simple_captcha.jpg
(Type the code from the image.)
Note that your comment may be edited or removed in the future, and that
your comment may appear alongside the original article on websites other
than this one.

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions

Your comment will be moderated before publication

Submit

Visitor comments

On the 1st and the day (adult jokes) when the beginning of reform and opening up. A young female teachers are on the culture of village women's classes. To class. The teacher wrote on the blackboard one day, and days. And to teach that day is the day. Day is the day. the day is the day. on the 1st is the day. women were followed to read. the day is the day. on the 1st is the day. suddenly have a woman stand up and asked. teacher. on the 1st day can be. on the 1st day of probably does not. the teacher asked. why. woman answered. that no one doll rice cooked ah.

Posted by: Anonymous , 13 Dec 2009

Congrats Rick sanchez in order to be dismissed by CNN, thanx for avoiding us seeing ur haughty point of view and also the spectacles fall.

Posted by: Shoe Lifts Girl , 09 Oct 2010

Browse posts by date

Cal_navigation_previousDecember 2011Cal_navigation_next
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
       
1234
       
567891011
       
131415161718
       
192022232425
       
262728293031

Newsletters

Get the latest financial news sent directly to your inbox

  • Best Practice
  • Business
  • Daily Newsletter
  • Essentials