Jaimie Kaffash

Tax Hack

A blog by Jaimie Kaffash, Accountancy Age’s tax reporter

ad

Poynter and the dangers of 'truth avoidance'

19 Dec 2007

  • Digg
  • Tweet

Sue Cameron's column in the FT on a Wednesday has caused a few flutters in Whitehall and Westminster ever since this piece revealing disaffection with the Brown regime.

She turns to Kieran Poynter's review of HMRC this morning (subscription required), whom she refers to as having shown 'heroic reticence' in not criticising HMRC. I'd agree with that description.

She goes on to discuss just how much PwC is being paid for the review, saying industry figures estimate it at £1,000 an hour. That's also probably correct (if you remember, the Rover investigators were racking up bills at £10,000 a day).

The combination of those two things is perhaps a mite unfair of course. But Poynter ought to realise there is a big risk in doing what he is doing.

Reviews of this kind are for politicians often an elaborate exercise in what you might call 'truth avoidance,' whereby the essential truth that everyone knows and feels (that HMRC is feeling the pinch from successive cuts) is hedged around and ignored in favour of literal truths ('I have seen no evidence thus far that would lead me to conclude that the statement given by you to parliament was inaccurate') designed to do nothing more than let politicians off the hook.

Like tax avoidance, the essence of what is happening is obscured by the letter and detail of what is happening. None of us, however, are ultimately fooled.

Adding your comment

We won't publish your address

simple_captcha.jpg
(Type the code from the image.)
Note that your comment may be edited or removed in the future, and that
your comment may appear alongside the original article on websites other
than this one.

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions

Your comment will be moderated before publication

Submit

Visitor comments

You do not even creatures such as the (adult jokes) for men and women sleep in a friend's room, woman drew a line said: "Once the line is a beast." Woke up with the men really have no control over line and fought bitter woman men a slap in the face: "You do not even like animals." The following day, men and women have a room with the sleeping woman as usual drew a line warning that men with the intention the night before the lessons of the last line of the results because he was nervous without success. Dawn, the woman has to play a slap men, said: "I did not think you are better than an animal."

Posted by: Anonymous , 13 Dec 2009

Browse posts by date

Cal_navigation_previousDecember 2011Cal_navigation_next
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
       
1234
       
567891011
       
131415161718
       
192022232425
       
262728293031

Newsletters

Get the latest financial news sent directly to your inbox

  • Best Practice
  • Business
  • Daily Newsletter
  • Essentials