A “VIRTUOUS CIRCLE” that exists for the Big Four is hindering the mid-tier’s ability to win FTSE 350 audits, according to the Competition Commission.
The commission, which is investigating competition issues in the market for large-listed audits, found that the Big Four’s ability to point to an extensive international network and audit engagement partners with relevant experience increases their chances of successfully tendering business.
In a working paper outlining an overview of its findings, the commission found that the “circle operates in reverse” for mid-tier firms, and that there is a “risk of prejudice” against non-Big-Four firms from companies which mid-tier firms have the capability to audit.
“Some of [the mid-tier] equally have extensive international networks (albeit with smaller member firms), but cannot point to the same level of experience of auditing large companies,” it said.
FTSE 350 decision-makers tend not to be concerned about price when determining audit provision, as such fees tend not to represent a large proportion of their overall budgets. The commission also found evidence of a perception that price and quality are linked – therefore undermining one route for mid-tier firms to win work – namely low cost provision.
“Equally, management aversion to shared audits means that mid-tier firms cannot demonstrate their capability by initially auditing say, one subsidiary or territory,” the commission said.
Having heard views from companies, investors and non-Big-Four firms that there is insufficient choice in the market, the commission will interview representatives from Deloitte, Ernst & Young, PwC and KPMG over their dominance of the market.
While the Big Four will be called upon to defend their position, the commission has said that it has seen no evidence of a strong link between market concentration and price and quality.
UHY Hacker Young, the national accountancy group, has named Chris Smith as a new partner in its London office
Curiosity killed the cat, but doesn't appear to afflict accounting watchdog the FRC, muses Colin
The Treasury Select Committee criticises the FRC for a 'lack of curiosity and diligence' in deciding to not investigate KPMG’s audit of HBOS before the publication of a report financial regulators, the FCA and PRA
Despite concerns over the viability of BHS, advisers including Grant Thornton were paid in the millions of pounds for their roles, according to the Work and Pensions and Business, Innovation and Skills Select Committees