Keep taxman away from tax scheme panel, says CIoT

by Kevin Reed

More from this author

18 Sep 2012

  • Comments
HM Revenue and Customs

THE TAXMAN MUST STAY CLEAR of an advisory panel proposed to determine whether tax schemes are abusive, according to the CIoT and ATT.

In response to the consultation on introducing a general anti-abuse rule (GAAR), the tax bodies warned that the proposals risk handing too much power to HM Revenue & Customs.

A panel for looking into the true purpose of tax schemes – and determining whether they are contrived to avoid tax – should have no HMRC representatives.

"The government have identified its purpose as being to help taxpayers and HMRC identify the borderline of where the GAAR applies," said CIoT president Patrick Stevens.

"To achieve this, we think it is necessary for it to be genuinely independent, drawing on those with current practical tax experience and with no HMRC representatives."

The introduction of the GAAR from April 2013 is too soon, the bodies added, particularly as the Finance Bill 2013 would not have been approved by parliament at that point.

"The result would be confusion and unfairness ," said ATT President Stuart McKinnon. "This guidance material will be crucial and needs to be available at least in final draft form by the time the GAAR comes into effect. Consequently, we think the GAAR should commence only after Royal Assent to Finance Bill 2013, ideally from 1 October. That will allow proper time to get the guidance in place."

The government should keep safeguards recommended in the Aaronson report, such as the one stating tax consequences must be the "sole or main purpose" of an arrangement and not just "one of the main purposes".

In PKF's consultation response, the firm calls for a dedicated unit within HMRC dedicated to dealing with GAAR issues.

"The best way for HMRC to help is to provide a clearance procedure so that people can check if the GAAR applies before submitting their returns. It should also establish a special unit to enforce the GAAR," said PKF national director of tax Lisa Macpherson.

"This means that the government will have to invest time and money to make the GAAR work properly in practice. If it doesn't make that investment, the GAAR will simply add to tax uncertainty rather than help clarify it, deterring the cautious but being ignored by those it was designed to catch – the worst tax avoiders."

Macpherson also raised concerns that HMRC is pushing for taxpayers to ‘self-assess' when the GAAR applies to them, which would then leave them open to HMRC altering their bill further down the line. The tax bill would "almost certainly" be incorrect when sent, she warned.

"It seems nonsensical that HMRC would encourage taxpayers to submit returns that they know to be wrong – usually, it charges penalties where incorrect returns are submitted."

Visitor comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Add your comment

We won't publish your address

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions

Your comment will be moderated before publication

  • Send

Charterhouse Accountants

Finance Officer

Charterhouse Accountants, Beaconsfield, Permanent, Full Time, £ Competitive




Get the latest financial news sent directly to your inbox

  • Best Practice
  • Business
  • Daily Newsletter
  • Essentials


Search for jobs
Click to search our database of all the latest accountancy roles

Create a profile
Click to set up your profile and let the best recruiters find you

Jobs by email
Sign up to receive regular updates with the latest roles suitable for you



Why budgeting fails: One management system is not enough

If budgeting is to have any value at all, it needs a radical overhaul. In today's dynamic marketplace, budgeting can no longer serve as a company's only management system; it must integrate with and support dedicated strategy management systems, process improvement systems, and the like. In this paper, Professor Peter Horvath and Dr Ralf Sauter present what's wrong with the current approach to budgeting and how to fix it.


iXBRL: Taking stock. Looking forward

In this white paper CCH provide checklists to help accountants and finance professionals both in practice and in business examine these issues and make plans. Also includes a case study of a large commercial organisation working through the first year of mandatory iXBRL filing.