Italy opens UK VAT uncertainty

The ECJ decision on Italian business Ampliscientifica case could cause major repercussions in the UK

Written by Nicholas Neveling

The tax affairs of little-known foreign companies have never caused much concern for HM Revenue & Customs and the Treasury ­ until now.

The company causing waves in the UK is Italian business Ampliscientifica, which has had a case on VAT referred to the European Court of Justice by Italy’s Supreme Court of Cassation.

Experts believe that the ECJ decision on the case, which will deal specifically with the use and structure of VAT groups, could cause major repercussions in the UK.

In a briefing note on the case, PricewaterhouseCoopers said: ‘Over the years, the UK has introduced extensive anti-avoidance legislation in relation to VAT groups, some of which [is] in common with the Italian referral in Ampliscientifica.’

PwC added: ‘UK taxpayers will be interested to see whether the eventual outcome of this case might call into question the legitimacy, or otherwise, of the UK’s anti-avoidance provisions.’

VAT group rules provide special provisions for groups and associated companies, allowing them to elect a single member to manage VAT.

The arrangement reduces the administrative burden on medium and large businesses that have subsidiaries and various divisions.

The case concerns whether VAT groups have a real economic substance, and whether and how tax authorities might challenge the groups set up for avoidance reasons.

Lorraine Parkin, a VAT partner at Grant Thornton, says the Ampliscientifica case will pose two questions to the ECJ that could affect the UK.

The first issue is whether HMRC should be allowed to treat some groups of companies differently to others for avoidance purposes, even though all the applicable groups qualify as VAT groups.

The second question deals with the length of time a VAT group has been assembled for, a question HMRC will be particularly interested in.

‘In Italy a group of companies have to be linked for a certain amount of time to qualify for VAT group status.

‘There are no temporal restrictions in UK rules, but if the ECJ says such restrictions are allowable, the UK taxman may be able to use temporal restrictions to prevent avoidance,’ Parkin said.

Enjoyed this article? Help spread the word:

Comments

White papers

Related jobs

More Accounting jobs

Spotlight

Find your next job

Find your next job

Advertisement

Salary Checker

Newsletters

Sign up here for the very latest news delivered to your inbox. Choose from the following options:

Search white papers

Search white papers

Advertisement

Have your say

Should fair value accounting be suspended in the wake of the market crisis?
Yes, it's a big part of the problem
No, don't shoot the messenger

Job of the week

More finance jobs

Advertisement

Your next job